What Justice Professionals Need to Know about Garrity: Myths and Realities

What Justice Professionals Need to Know about Garrity: Myths and Realities
Duration: 60 Minutes
Module 1Resources
Recorded on: 2019-07-18
Unit 1Slide Deck: What Justice Professionals Need to Know about Garrity: Myths and Realities
Unit 2Workbook: What Justice Professionals Need to Know about Garrity
Unit 3Recording: What Justice Professionals Need to Know about Garrity

The United States Supreme Court decision of Garrity v. New Jersey became the baseline in which government employees have the right to be free from compulsory self-incrimination. However, the concept and details of the Garrity rules are sometimes misinterpreted producing myths surrounding it.

To debunk these myths and shed light on the nitty-gritty of Garrity Rights is Rick Hodsdon. A Justice Clearinghouse regular, Rick is one of the most trusted authorities when it comes to civil and criminal matters in corrections, law enforcement operations, criminal prosecution, and employment law. He’s shared his expertise by training thousands of government staff on these topics. He’s currently the Assistant County Attorney in Stillwater, MN where he represents the county and its criminal justice agencies.

Points he unpacked on this course are:

  • The Fifth Amendment as the precursor from which the Garrity Concept stemmed from.
  • The types of immunity that may be granted to a government employee under the Garrity rule.
  • Dissecting the facts and details of the Garrity v. New Jersey case from which the Garrity rule originated and its applicability.
  • Understanding the Gardner v. Broderick case which when synthesized with the Garrity v. New Jersey case outlines the scope and restriction of the Garrity concept.
  • The exception when a plaintiff has no right to Garrity immunity.
  • The key concept of compulsion to look out for in Garrity issues and instances when it is unclear whether there is compulsion or not.
  • The burden of proof on the prosecution to prove that evidence presented is free of taint derived from immunized testimony as seen in State v. Gault.
  • The problematic nature of running a criminal and a personnel investigation simultaneously in ensuring there is no tainted material used for prosecution.
  • Instances when there isn’t unconstitutional coercion such as disciplinary action short of termination as seen in Chan v. Wodnicki.
  • Refusing to testify despite being granted Garrity warning and immunity as grounds for termination.
  • The applicability of Garrity rule even to off-duty incidents.
  • Highlighting that there is no constitutional right to lie and that once subjected to Garrity immunity, testifying untruthfully is not permissible.
  • Webinar attendees’ inquiries during the Q&A are about:
    • Navigating the Garrity principle in conjunction with Giglio requirements and Miranda rights.
    • The non-applicability of the Garrity rule to pre-employment background checks.
    • Using Garrity to government contractors or consultants and governmental bodies overseeing other agencies.
    • What private employees can use in place of Garrity rights.
    • Guidelines if to run an internal and criminal investigation at the same time.
    • An example of reverse Garrity.


Resources Mentioned During Webinar


Audience Comments:

  • “Clear, useful presentation with good examples.” — Wayne
  • “I have a greater understanding of how Garrity applies to all public sector employees.” — Tony
  • “I learned so much, because the presentation was systematic, well-organized, had good examples and good slides. Excellent!” — Joni
  • “How knowledgeable the presenter was and the displayed information.” — Carlos


** This webinar has been certified by the National Sheriffs' Association and may be eligible for Continuing Education Units through your POST. Please consult your local certification processes for additional details. Paid subscribers that attend will be able to download a jointly issued attendance certificate that includes the National Sheriffs' Association logo.
Additional Resources
4 years ago
After the Webinar: Garrity – Myths and Realities. Q&A with Rick Hodsdon
Webinar presenter Rick Hodsdon answered a number of your questions after his presentation, What Just […]
Difficult Employees
5 years ago
Dealing With The Dark Side: How To Handle Your Most Difficult Employees
Every organization has got its own share of good and bad. There are your superstar employees – the […]
5 years ago
Giglio, Brady and Discipline Disclosures: What Prosecutors and Law Enforcement Need to Know
It is mandated that the government, specifically law enforcement and prosecution, is bound to disclo […]
6 years ago
Employing Background Checks in Your Hiring Process: Legal Requirements vs Current Research
Employers use background checks – both criminal and credit history – when deciding which candida […]
8 years ago
Whining, Sniveling, Malcontents: Dealing With Them and Saving Your Organization
During this webinar you will learn: The various roles the leaders of the 21st Century need to m […]